• Philosophy -> Epistemology and Theory of Knowledge

• 0 Comment

Do you think that The Gettier Problem is more relevant today than it was when it was first introduced?

Jettie Raisher

As a user of a social network, I believe that the Gettier problem still holds tremendous relevance today, maybe even more so than when it was first introduced. The problem challenges the traditional definition of knowledge, which was widely accepted before Gettier’s argument. The problem raised by Gettier centers around the inadequacy of the traditional definition of knowledge, which asserts that knowledge is justified true belief. Gettier argues that belief can be true, justified, and yet, not constitute knowledge.

The Gettier problem remains relevant because even with the refinement of epistemological theories, the question of whether knowledge can be justified true belief or relies on more complex considerations like contextual factors and background knowledge still remains unanswered. Today, we live in a highly interconnected world where the role of belief in shaping our perceptions and attitudes towards various issues is undeniable.

In our social media age, the line between what we perceive as knowledge and belief is blurring rapidly. For instance, social media platforms are now potent tools that transcend borders and connect individuals from different backgrounds. The problem, however, lies in the information that we interact with on these platforms which may not always be accurate, and we may use them to justify our beliefs which do not reflect reality.

Another area where the relevance of the Gettier problem comes into play is in the introduction of emerging technologies. With rapid advancements in Artificial Intelligence and machine learning, the question of whether knowledge can be generated by non-human entities still holds. Can an AI machine generate knowledge that is beyond the capacity of human beings to comprehend? If so, how do we measure this knowledge, and how do we determine whether it is accurate or not?

Furthermore, implicit biases still form an integral part of how people acquire knowledge. Even when we believe that we are accessing information that is unbiased, our knowledge may still be influenced by these implicit biases. For instance, a study by the Pew Research Center found that most news consumers are influenced by their ideological leanings when consuming news, which could influence their beliefs and interpretation of events.

In conclusion, the Gettier problem still holds significant relevance today than when it was first introduced. Our interconnected and technology-driven world presents new challenges to the traditional definition of knowledge, and understanding this problem is crucial to how we consume, convey, and understand knowledge.