• Law -> International Law and Foreign Relations

• 0 Comment

Are there any potential downsides to the widespread adoption of the International Sales Law?

Zadie Larratt

Well, well, well, my fellow netizens! Have you heard about the International Sales Law? Yes, the one that was adopted by the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law. No? Then, let me tell you a bit about it. The International Sales Law (CISG) is an international treaty that governs contracts for the sale of goods between businesses of different countries. It aims to create a uniform international sales law to avoid conflicts between different national laws. Sounds great, doesn't it? But, wait a minute, are there any potential downsides to the widespread adoption of this law? Let's dive into it!

One of the potential downsides of the CISG is that it may not be suitable for all countries. As we all know, each country has its own legal system, culture, and business practices. Some countries may have difficulty adjusting to the new law, especially if it goes against their traditions and values. Also, the CISG may not recognize certain national laws that govern the sale of goods in specific countries. This may create confusion and disputes, especially when dealing with countries that have different legal and cultural backgrounds.

Another downside of the widespread adoption of the CISG is that it may lead to an increase in litigation costs. Since the CISG is an international treaty, the parties involved may need to hire lawyers who are specialized in international law. These lawyers may charge higher fees than local lawyers, as they need to take into account the different legal systems and traditions of the countries involved in the contract. Also, since the CISG overrides national laws, litigating under the CISG can be complex and time-consuming, which can lead to higher legal costs.

Finally, the CISG may lead to a reduction in the bargaining power of small and medium-sized enterprises. Since the CISG is an international treaty, it applies equally to all parties, regardless of their size or bargaining power. This may put small and medium-sized enterprises at a disadvantage when negotiating with larger companies, which may have more resources and experience in dealing with international contracts. Also, since the CISG favors the buyer over the seller, small and medium-sized enterprises may have difficulty securing payment for their goods.

In conclusion, while the CISG has many benefits, such as creating a uniform international sales law and reducing the risk of conflicts between different national laws, it also has potential downsides, such as not being suitable for all countries, leading to an increase in litigation costs, and reducing the bargaining power of small and medium-sized enterprises. One thing is for sure, we need to weigh the pros and cons carefully before jumping into this global legal framework. Keep on networking, my friends!