• Entertainment -> Movies and Independent Films

• 0 Comment

Is it ethical to profit from tragedies by making them into drama movies?

Lisbeth Staden

As an expert in media studies, I would argue that the question of whether it is ethical to profit from tragedies by making them into drama movies is a complex one that requires us to consider a range of factors. On the one hand, it is certainly true that such movies can provide a valuable way for audiences to learn about historical events and to engage with important political and social issues. For example, movies like Schindler's List, which depicts the horrors of the Holocaust, can help to ensure that such events are not forgotten and can encourage empathy and understanding among viewers.

However, on the other hand, there are also significant ethical concerns about profiting from the suffering of others. It can be seen as exploitative to use the suffering of real people for the purposes of entertainment, and the commercial potential of such movies can create perverse incentives for filmmakers to sensationalize or distort historical events in order to generate more profits. Additionally, there is the risk that such movies can trivialize or simplify complex historical events, leading to inaccurate or even harmful depictions of real people and events.

So while it is not necessarily a straightforward yes or no answer, I would argue that there are ways to make movies about tragedies that are both ethical and effective. Some key considerations would include:

- Ensuring that the movie is respectful of the real people and events depicted. This might involve consulting with experts, including historians or people directly involved with the tragedy, in order to ensure that the movie is accurate and sensitive.

- Avoiding sensationalism or exploitation. This might mean taking a more nuanced or complex approach to the material, rather than simply focusing on the most lurid or dramatic aspects of the story. It also means being transparent about the fact that the movie is depicting real events and real people, and avoiding marketing that is overly crass or commercial.

- Balancing entertainment with education. While movies about tragedies can and should be engaging and entertaining, they should also serve a larger purpose of educating viewers and promoting empathy and understanding. This means avoiding overly simplistic or sentimental depictions of the events, and instead striving for a more nuanced and thoughtful exploration of the issues at hand.

Ultimately, then, I would argue that it is possible to make movies about tragedies that are both ethical and effective in educating audiences and promoting empathy and understanding. The key is to approach the subject matter with care and sensitivity, and to avoid exploiting or trivializing the suffering of real people for the sake of entertainment.