• Philosophy -> Political and Social Philosophy

• 0 Comment

How does multiculturalism compare to assimilation policies in terms of promoting diversity in society?

Cristi Southerill

Hi friend,

That's an interesting question you've raised. The promotion of diversity in society is a critical issue that requires careful consideration. The two approaches that you've mentioned: multiculturalism and assimilation policies, are both aimed at achieving this desired objective, but they take entirely different paths to get there. Let's break down how they compare in their efforts to promote diversity in society.

Multiculturalism is an approach that celebrates cultural differences and aims to create a more inclusive society by accommodating cultural diversity. By acknowledging and respecting all cultures, this approach fosters an environment where a diverse range of individuals can coexist peacefully, emphasizing the equal status of all cultures. Multicultural policies are designed to encourage respect and recognition while minimizing discrimination and promoting inter-cultural exchange. The focus is on understanding and learning cross-cultural differences and creating a society that accommodates and appreciates these differences.

On the other hand, assimilation policies aim to create a more homogenous society by encouraging minority groups to adopt the customs, language, and values of the dominant culture. This process of assimilation involves the abandonment of one's native culture and adopting the cultural norms of the majority population. Advocates of assimilation often believe that it is the only way to ensure social unity and national identity since a single culture can be shared.

So how do these two approaches compare in terms of promoting diversity in society? While assimilation aims to unify cultures under one common identity, multiculturalism emphasizes and retains cultural differences to create one larger inclusive society. Multiculturalism actively promotes diversity in society as a source of strength, pride, and a means of reinforcing the distinctiveness of various groups. By embracing the diversity and cultural heritage of different groups, multiculturalism eliminates discrimination that can lead to social division and marginalization, creating a more inclusive society where people from different backgrounds can live together peacefully.

Assimilation policies, however, work towards a less diverse society by diluting the minority cultures and replacing them with the dominant culture. While assimilation policies can promote and advance social cohesion and unity, it can also destroy many cultural identities and their accompanying traditions. In extreme cases, policies emphasizing assimilation have resulted in various types of discrimination, such as forced removal, cultural repression, and stigmatization of minority cultures. This elimination of cultural diversity is detrimental to a society's overall progress and discourages social integration amongst differing cultures.

In conclusion, I believe that multiculturalism is a better approach to promote diversity in society, compared to assimilation policies. By celebrating cultural diversity and promoting respect, multiculturalism allows different cultures to coexist peacefully. Multicultural policies aim to encourage cross-cultural exchange, create harmony and eliminate discrimination. Multiculturalism promotes the existence of cultural diversity, preserving and including the diversity of traditions in a community. Multiculturalism, therefore, is the ideal approach to building a truly diverse and inclusive society, promoting respect and understanding for all individuals.