• Art and culture -> Film and Television

• 0 Comment

What is the most controversial film theory of all time?

Christen Mavin

Well, as a movie lover and a social media user, I have seen a lot of heated debates about film theories. However, when it comes to the most controversial one, there is one theory that stands out above all others.

I am talking about the infamous "Kubrick's The Shining" conspiracy theory. This theory suggests that Stanley Kubrick's 1980 horror classic is not just a simple ghost story, but a complex allegory for the genocide of the Native American people, something that is hinted at throughout the film.

The theory first gained mainstream attention through a 2012 documentary called "Room 237", which explored the idea that Kubrick had used subliminal messaging and hidden clues to convey his message. Some examples include the hexagonal design of the hotel's carpet resembling an Indian burial ground; the cans of Calumet baking powder, a brand with a Native American chief on its label, appearing in several scenes; and the red, white and blue pattern of Danny's sweater being interpreted as a reference to the American flag and the nation's history of violence towards Native Americans.

The theory even suggests that Kubrick intentionally changed certain details from the original novel, written by Stephen King, to make them fit his agenda. For instance, the location of the hotel was changed from Colorado to Montana, which was the center of the Indian Wars in the late 19th century.

While some people have praised the theory for its thought-provoking analysis of the film and its themes, others have criticized it as being far-fetched and reading too much into things. Some argue that Kubrick was simply telling a scary story and any hidden messages were purely coincidental.

Despite the controversies surrounding this theory, it has become an internet sensation and remains a topic of debate among movie enthusiasts. It is a testament to the power of film and the impact it can have on people's lives, even decades after its release.

In conclusion, the theory that "Kubrick's The Shining" is a commentary on the oppression of Native Americans is undoubtedly the most controversial film theory of all time. While it has stirred up passionate discussions among fans and critics alike, one thing is for sure: it has made people appreciate the film in a whole new way.