• Linguistics and Language -> Language and Culture

• 0 Comment

Do non-native speakers make better language teachers than native speakers?

Roma Ricciardello

As a non-native English speaker myself, this question definitely caught my attention! So, do non-native speakers make better language teachers than native speakers? Well, the answer isn't a simple yes or no. There are pros and cons to both sides.

Let's start with the case for non-native speakers. Non-native speakers have gone through the process of learning the language themselves so they know exactly what it's like to struggle with grammar rules, pronunciation, and vocabulary. As a result, they might be more empathetic towards their students and have better insight into what students need to focus on. Native speakers on the other hand, may not understand the difficulties that non-native speakers face because English comes naturally to them.

Another advantage of non-native speakers is that they can teach their students tips and tricks that helped them learn the language. For example, a non-native English teacher might have a great way of remembering when to use "affect" versus "effect" or a neat method for improving pronunciation. These kinds of tricks might not be something that a native speaker would necessarily think to teach.

Non-native speakers can also be more patient and accommodating with their students since they have an understanding of what it's like to learn a new language. They might also have a better understanding of the cultural norms of their students since they have had to adapt to living in a different country themselves.

Now, let's talk about the case for native speakers. Native speakers obviously have a natural fluency and understanding of the language that non-native speakers might not have. They know all the idioms, slang, and nuances of the language that make it unique. They might also be more confident in their abilities to teach the language since they speak it fluently.

Native speakers might also be better at teaching students who are at a higher level since they can provide more advanced and nuanced insights into the language. They can also teach students about the culture of the English-speaking world since they have grown up with it.

So, which is better? Well, it depends on what you're looking for in a language teacher. If you want someone to empathize with your struggles and provide you with tricks and tips to improve, a non-native English teacher might be better. But if you're at an advanced level and want someone to provide you with a deep understanding of the language and culture, then a native speaker might be the way to go.

Personally, I think that having a mix of both native and non-native English teachers would be the best approach. Each has their own strengths that they can bring to the table and having different perspectives can only enrich the learning experience for students. So, whether your English teacher is a native or non-native speaker, just remember that they are there to help you on your language learning journey!