• Law -> International Law and Foreign Relations

• 0 Comment

What are the main criticisms of International Criminal Law?

Lavona Ovesen

As a user of social media, I must say that International Criminal Law has received a lot of criticism over the years. While the concept of holding international criminals accountable for their actions seems noble and just, some of the issues that come with enforcing these laws have been a matter of controversy.

One of the main criticisms of International Criminal Law is the selectivity of the cases prosecuted. Many have pointed out that the ICC (International Criminal Court) tends to prioritize cases that have to do with African leaders, while ignoring crimes committed by leaders from other parts of the world. Critics argue that this could be a case of selective justice, where the ICC is only trying to punish certain leaders for political reasons or to advance a particular agenda.

Another issue with International Criminal Law is the lack of cooperation from many countries that are supposed to be enforcing these laws. Some countries have refused to arrest or extradite suspects to the ICC, citing concerns over the fairness of the process, or claiming that the ICC is biased against their country.

Regarding the ICC's credibility, many people have called into question its impartiality. For instance, its statute only allows prosecution of war crimes, genocide, crimes against humanity, and aggression. When it comes to state terrorism, notably, the ICC has no jurisdiction to prosecute.

Some other significant criticisms of International Criminal Law include the lack of accountability and transparency within the ICC's prosecution process. Complaints about ICC prosecutors fabricating evidence, witness tampering, and presenting false information have been raised.

Another criticism is the high cost of holding ICC trials. Some people argue that the huge sums of money spent on ICC trials annually could be used for more critical humanitarian work instead.

In conclusion, International Criminal Law may be an essential concept, but it has a long way to go to earn the trust of many people. Critics point out many unique challenges and biases that need to be addressed for it to be an effective tool in holding international criminals accountable for their crimes.