• Entertainment -> Video Games and Board Games

• 0 Comment

How do themed board games compare to their non-themed counterparts?

Harm Seamen

Themed board games, also known as "licensed games," have been gaining more popularity in recent years, partly due to their association with popular franchises such as Star Wars, Game of Thrones, or Marvel. However, the question remains: how do these games compare to their non-themed counterparts in terms of gameplay, replayability, and overall enjoyment?

Firstly, it's important to acknowledge that not all themed board games are created equal. Some may be cash-grabs that rely heavily on the brand's name without adding much to the actual gameplay experience. On the other hand, there are licensed games that are well-designed, faithful to the source material, and offer a unique perspective on the franchise.

When it comes to gameplay, themed board games have the advantage of tapping into the players' knowledge and appreciation of the franchise. For instance, a Star Trek-themed game may have players commanding their own starship, exploring strange new worlds, and encountering enemy vessels in a way that feels authentic to the show. This immersion can be a powerful factor in engaging players and making the game more memorable.

However, non-themed board games also have their strengths. Since they don't rely on an existing brand, they have more freedom to explore original concepts, mechanics, and themes. Moreover, non-themed games can appeal to a wider audience, as they don't require players to be familiar with a particular franchise. This can be a significant advantage in introducing new people to the hobby and expanding the market.

In terms of replayability, both types of games can offer a lot of value. Themed games often include multiple scenarios, character cards, or other components that add variability to the game. For example, a Batman-themed game may have players facing different supervillains each time they play, each with their own unique abilities and schemes. Non-themed games, on the other hand, can have randomized setups, modular boards, or card decks that create different experiences each time. Additionally, non-themed games can be modified, expanded, or combined with other games to enhance their replayability.

Finally, the question of which type of game is more enjoyable is largely subjective and depends on the player's preferences. Some players may prefer the depth of strategy and narrative found in themed games, while others may enjoy the abstract puzzles and mechanics of non-themed games. Ultimately, what matters most is whether the game offers engaging gameplay, balanced mechanics, and a satisfying experience.

In conclusion, themed board games and non-themed games have their respective strengths and weaknesses, but both can provide plenty of entertainment and engagement for players. As with any hobby, it's best to try out different types of games and see what resonates with you personally. Whether you're a fan of Star Wars, Settlers of Catan, or something entirely different, there's likely a board game out there that will capture your imagination and keep you coming back for more.